Third-party risk is a serious headache for every organization, and non-profits are no exception. In fact, non-profits like charities, foundations, professional societies, and trade associations have all the same risks as for-profit entities, plus a few more besides. 

Non-profit entities generally work with limited budgets, small teams, and volunteer workers, which handicaps their ability to carry out thorough risk assessments and management. What’s more, compliance and trust are particularly important for fundraising and to retain support from donors and beneficiaries. 

At the same time, your reduced resources make you more likely to rely heavily on outsourced services. You might also operate in high-risk environments, and handle sensitive data about vulnerable populations. All of this exposes you to more third-party risk.

Trying to tread a safe path with constrained resources in such a challenging environment means that third-party risk management (TPRM) solutions are non-negotiable. You need the right tools and strategies to ensure operational continuity, regulatory compliance, and donor and beneficiary trust. 

In this article, we’ll discuss the unique challenges that non-profits face in third-party risk management, and share advice for building an effective non-profit TPRM strategy that protects your organization and maintains operational continuity. 

What is Third-Party Risk Management (TPRM)?

Third-party risk management (TPRM) is a vital program that protects non-profits from the risks associated with external vendors, partners, service providers, and other entities. Non-profits work with a whole range of third parties, including payment processors, cloud services, and logistics providers as well as fundraising platforms and marketing agencies. 

Vulnerabilities and security gaps in any one of these entities can open you up to data breaches, cyberattacks that disrupt critical systems, and regulatory fines and penalties for non-compliance. Additionally, if a third party can’t deliver vital services, you might not be able to maintain operational continuity. 

Robust non-profit TPRM helps safeguard your organization from financial losses, reputational harm, and operational disruptions.  It’s a systematic strategy that proactively detects, identifies, and addresses third-party risks to prevent threats from damaging your organization. 

Effective TPRM is made up of many different processes, along with automated tools and centralized data analytics. Structured third-party risk assessments; due diligence; continuous monitoring of vendor performance, security, and compliance; and risk mitigation tactics like contractual safeguards and incident response planning all play an important role in powerful TPRM for non-profits. 

Why is TPRM Crucial for Non-Profits?

TPRM is important for every organization, but non-profits need it more than most. Many non-profits have smaller budgets which hamper them from buying comprehensive risk assessment tools, hiring specialized staff, or engaging in continuous monitoring. They’re more vulnerable to a range of risks, including cyberattacks, regulatory non-compliance, financial fraud, and data breaches, but they don’t have the resources to identify and mitigate them. 

Smaller budgets also mean smaller professional teams. Many non-profits depend on volunteers, who are well-meaning and hard-working but don’t usually have the specialized skills needed for effective risk management. Even paid employees may only work part-time, which can lead to gaps in risk mitigation coverage. 

This makes it even more important for non-profits to establish a structured TPRM framework that helps them minimize potential disruptions and financial setbacks caused by third-party issues. An organized TPRM strategy ensures that high-risk issues are addressed quickly, before they can escalate into serious incidents. 

Key Third-Party Risk Areas for Non-Profits

Non-profits don’t just have fewer resources to handle third-party risks. They also often work in high-risk environments, which exposes them to more risks than a typical for-profit organization. Data security is a hot topic, both to protect sensitive financial information about donors, and to safeguard beneficiaries who might belong to vulnerable populations. 

Depending on their field of work, non-profits might have to work with partners who aren’t as reliable as they’d like. This increases the risks of operational disruption when a critical vendor can’t deliver their normal services, and of regulatory non-compliance. Many third-party entities are in different regions and operate under different regulatory frameworks, which increases the compliance burden. 

Additionally, reputation is extremely important for non-profits. If they’re associated with an entity or an individual that’s involved in shady or fraudulent activities, it can seriously harm their ability to raise funds and carry out their work. External bodies often examine non-profit activities very closely for unethical behavior or mishandling of funds, so there’s no leeway for the smallest misstep. 

Key Steps to Building a TPRM Program for Non-Profits

An effective non-profit TPRM program should be structured and tailored to your specific risk tolerance and risk landscape. To achieve this, you’ll need to cover a number of specific steps. These include: 

  • Identifying all the third parties that you work with and understanding their relationship with your organization 
  • Carrying out thorough risk assessment that considers context and categorizes risks according to priority 
  • Developing a risk mitigation plan that outlines ways to minimize risks as much as possible 
  • Establishing ongoing vendor monitoring that continuously tracks vendor performance and compliance 

Identifying Third-Party Relationships

The foundations of a successful TPRM program for non-profits involves full visibility into your third-party network. You need to create a comprehensive inventory of all your vendors, contractors, partners, and service providers, as well as their third parties. This inventory enables you to understand the scope and scale of your third-party engagements. 

Once you have this inventory, you can begin to organize your third-party relationships according to their level of risk. This requires considering how critical each entity is to your mission and operations, and the impact any incident could have on your reputation. 

Risk Assessment and Categorization

The next step is to assess the risks posed by each third party, using a structured process. It’s important to evaluate what level of access they have to your sensitive data; their cybersecurity measures; compliance with regulations like data protection and financial reporting standards; and financial stability, so that you can rely on them for uninterrupted services. 

Then you can categorize risks into high, medium, and low priorities. This way, you can focus your risk management efforts and resources on the most critical areas, to make sure that high-risk relationships are closely monitored without either neglecting or wasting resources on medium and low-risk vendors.

Developing a Risk Mitigation Plan

Now you’re ready to put together a plan to mitigate and minimize the risks that you’ve identified. It begins with clear policies for vendor onboarding and contacts. You want to build standardized procedures for new vendor due diligence so that no one slips through the cracks. 

Your contracts should include specific clauses that define vendor responsibilities for data security, regulatory compliance, and financial reporting, with consequences for non-compliance. Plan a schedule for frequent audits and compliance reviews, so that you’ll spot and deal with potential issues before they escalate into significant problems. 

Ongoing Vendor Monitoring

Finally, TPRM is an ongoing process for non-profits and for for-profit organizations. You want to constantly track and assess vendor performance and compliance, so you can quickly detect and address any gaps between your requirements and third-party performance. 

Continuous monitoring needs to cover a range of areas, including financial stability, legal standing, changes in ownership, performance metrics, and regulatory compliance. It might involve a number of channels, such as reports and dashboards from automated tools, feedback from internal stakeholders, and documentation reviews. 

Tools and Software to Streamline Non-Profit TPRM

As you’ve probably already discovered, it’s very difficult to keep on top of TPRM using manual processes, especially when you’re a non-profit with limited human resources. This is where TPRM tools step into the picture. Thankfully, there are many platforms and solutions that enable non-profits to manage vendor risks efficiently with limited resources. 

For example, vendor management systems (VMS) are solutions that centralize third-party relationship tracking. They often feature automated workflows for vendor onboarding, risk assessment, and contract management, with real-time insights into vendor performance and compliance. These help you maintain consistent and thorough risk management processes so you can make data-driven decisions and quickly address any issues.

There is also specialized TPRM software that assesses and monitors third-party risks. These offer continuous monitoring for vendor cybersecurity practices, automated risk scoring, and comprehensive reporting, delivering detailed, dynamic risk profiles. They help reveal potential vulnerabilities in the vendor ecosystem, and alert you to changes in vendor status or behavior that might indicate increased risk. Some TPRM tools integrate with other cybersecurity tools to create a seamless flow of information and enhance overall organizational security. 

Overcoming Common TPRM Challenges in the Non-Profit Sector

For all the reasons we already mentioned — limited resources, few employees with risk management skills, and a high-risk environment — it’s not easy to implement effective TPRM in a non-profit organization. 

This makes it all the more important to establish a structured process for evaluating and prioritizing risks, so that your precious resources are put to the best use. Otherwise, serious risks could slip through the cracks and cause significant damage to your entity, while time and money are wasted on third parties that are lower risk. 

Risk management experts can help you to build an effective TPRM system, either working with you as partners or operating as external service providers. They bring training and support for your employees, to help ensure that everybody understands the importance of third-party risk management. 

External experts should be just one pillar in a culture of accountability and risk awareness. You want all your workers, both volunteer and salaried, to feel part of a broader effort to minimize and mitigate risk. Everyone should know how to recognize red flags that should be reported to risk management experts, and basic actions to reduce risk. 

Benefits of a Strong TPRM Program for Non-Profits

Building a strong TPRM program can seem like a lot of work for your non-profit, but it’s worth the effort. Robust third-party risk management helps ensure that your organization can continue serving your audience and working towards your mission. It equips you to spot potential third-party failures while they are still on the horizon so that you can act to prevent them from damaging your operational continuity. 

Effective TPRM procedures also proactively improve your organization’s standing and reputation. You’ll demonstrate your commitment to safeguarding sensitive data and adhering to ethical practices, which helps to build trust both among your donors and your beneficiary population. 

Just as importantly, you’ll be better able to avoid regulatory non-compliance and the penalties and fines that it can bring. Proactive risk management ensures that you identify and act to mitigate any legal, financial, or cybersecurity risks before they escalate into major incidents, empowering you to prevent data breaches and other forms of non-compliance. 

Non-Profit TPRM 

To recap, third-party risk management is crucial for every non-profit. It’s a critical element in avoiding fines and penalties, ensuring operational continuity, and forging a positive reputation among donors, beneficiaries, and regulatory bodies. 

Given your limited resources, you need to find smart ways to bake TPRM into your operations and workflows. Focus on nurturing a culture of risk awareness, implementing structured procedures for assessing and prioritizing risk, and setting up processes for continuous monitoring across your third-party network. 

It’s up to you whether you do this through a partnership with risk management experts, outsourcing to TPRM specialists, or deploying user-friendly TPRM solutions. Either way, it’s best to start small with simple procedures that you’re confident your employees can adhere to, and then scale your efforts over time. 

Ready to protect your organization with effective non-profit TPRM? Contact Panorays to learn more.

Non-Profit TPRM FAQs